Nino’s Pizzeria

Reviews

• Nader A.

  star star star star star 22 July 2026

  The calendar on the wall is from May 1962. The pictures on the wall tell a story of a pizzeria as old as 1960s. The pizza is different that any other pizza in the area. Perhaps it is made with the same quality that they made it back in 60s. Delicious. Good price
  
  Quick update: tonight we had a large sausage, mushrooms and onion. It was only $20 - really good price. Very good pizza and very generous with ingredients. I am updating my review of Nino's to 5 stars. They deserve it.

• Nicole F.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 19 July 2026

  Nino's... I ordered take out from you the other day and the pizza, I have zero complaints. The pizza was a cheese and pepperoni ($14) for a large. Great pricing for a large pizza and you guys use the "good" pepperonis! The sauce was smooth, savory and had the right amount of spices.
  Now for the gross and comical piece of my order. Medium wings- SO BAD. I almost laughed when I saw how teeny-tiny and pathetic these wings were. I don't know who your distributor is for your wings but you may want to reconsider. The wings were the size of my pinky finger (acrylic nail not included). They were literally the equivalent to the to-go blue cheese container lid. You have got to be kidding me? Do better Nino's. On top of the size issue, the inside meat of the wing was repulsive. I gagged when I took my second bite of my third wing. The insides were dark purple and veiny. The wings had a chewy, rubber consistency and typing this is making my stomach hurt all over again.
  I threw the rest of the wings in the garbage because I was so disgusted. I don't know if it was just a bad batch but I was so disappointed. I know you "get what you pay for" so I don't know if I will ever take another chance and potential illness.

• Ernest O.

  star star star star star 17 July 2026

  Best pizza in Rochester. I remember when Nino first opened many years ago on Portland Ave.  I was a very loyal customer for many years. Still makes the best pizza you could ask for.  Trust me on this.

• Anne F.

  star star star star star_border 9 July 2026

  This is the best pizza I've ever had in Rochester in all my 35 years! Iordwred a mushroom and onion pizza. The dough was perfectly baked. It was light and very tasty. The sauce was nice and thick and the seasonings were nice. The mushrooms were clearly fresh and not from a can. And I  loved biting into big chucks! The onions were nice and thick and very tasty. I can't wait to go back. And the ONLY reason I didn't give it 5 stars was the place stunk of cigarette smoke! We had to wait outside for our pizza and then even ate it outside because of the stale stench of cigarettes. Too bad too.

• James C.

  star star star star star 2 July 2026

  Best pizza on the planet!!
  Can't beat the price and the produce is locally bought and the ingredients are from imported from Italy. What more could you ask for. The wings are fantastic and they are huge!!! You can't get a great Sicilian pizza unless you try Nino's! Go there, you won't be sorry.